The Problem with “Millennials”

A friend of mine, Ryan Stephens, recently posted a list of his favourite Gen Y blogs, as well as others that come highly recommended, in the hopes of paring the 35 shortlisted ones down to a “Top 10″ of sorts. For some reason, I’m on that list. So are a few other blogs I read regularly (and really enjoy), like Hoehn’s Musings, I Will Teach You To Be Rich, and Ben Casnocha.

There are a lot of them on there that don’t deserve anything.

I haven’t read most of the blogs on the list, though some look fairly intriguing. My issue is with the standard “Gen Y blogger” stereotype… one that I see far too often.

Why do so many of my “ambitious” peers and contemporaries insist on writing about their “expertise,” while settling for standard (or, worse, boring) jobs? I’ve read far too many self-important Gen-Y-related posts, ones where the author is desperately inflating his or her ego by reciting generic, recycled tips about “how to ask your boss for a raise.” Where’s the value in that?

I’m guilty of this as much as anyone else on that list. I’ve written simple news posts before, or little tactical things that I know aren’t original but have still helped me in my projects. But there is a difference, I think, between what I (and others who I like) write, and what the typical Gen-Y-blogger does:

I (and others like me) try to offer value to you, or at least your project. We want you to do something, and we try to help you get it done (if we’re not doing it ourselves).

The others try to offer advice to you. They want you to succeed in the workplace.

Then again, neither of these approaches is “wrong.” I just side with the people who are getting things done, who are implementing change… or, at least, the ones who are trying to.

6 Responses to “The Problem with “Millennials””

  1. charhoehn@gmail.com Says:

    Cheers, Aidan. I’m with you on those last few paragraphs. People like Casnocha and Holiday (who wasn’t on the list?!) have something deeper in all of their posts. They write things to encourage personal growth, it seems, not only for themselves but for all their readers. You walk away from their writing wanting to push yourself to become a better person. Most “Gen Y” blogs simply teach you how to be a better cog in the machine.

  2. alexjmann Says:

    The most difficult (but most necessary) blogging transformation is the leap from writing only for yourself to actively writing for and engaging other people. If you look at early entries from those that have been in the game longer than us, the same pattern exists.

    The value in a blog comes from the selflessness, which is unfortunately uncommon in the Gen Y space. But, as you said, we’re all guilty of it sometimes.

  3. Nick Says:

    Crap.

    You know, I really hope that I’m not writing like that.

    I’m happy with my job, to a point – it’s not perfect, but I like to think that the advice I offer on my website (PsychoticResumes.com) isn’t just cookie-cutter crap… There’s a reason I don’t charge for it, I mean – I’ve seen loads of my friends get finagled by corporate bastards. I just wanted to give them the tools to fight back.

    Everything that I write about is something that I actively fight for or believe in… and I love that what I write about encourages people to think and, even if they disagree, to start working towards things that will improve themselves.

    Now I’m going to have to go back and look at it in another light. I don’t want my friends to become just another cog. I don’t know if that’s what I’m doing but I’d better make damn sure.

    Thanks for the article, I think ;)

    -Nick
    PsychoticResumes.com

  4. Aidan Says:

    @Charlie – I agree with the sentiment, but wouldn’t necessarily use the phrase “cog in the machine”. A cog turns, regardless of how it feels, and never asks for vacations or raises. I don’t think even the worst posts I’ve read encourage obeying others’ blindly.

    @Alex – That’s the gap that all writers need to (or, at least, should) eventually leap. My biggest issue is that a whole culture — one that I belong to, at least in the general sense — is slowly being branded as inexperienced writers who can’t think outside their box. Maclean’s had a great article about this recently: http://tinyurl.com/macleans-millennials

    @Nick – So long as you have a mission for change and/or a desire to motivate others to think or do originally, you’re doing great in my books! I checked out Psychotic Resumes, and while I don’t necessarily agree with some things you say (I live my online life VERY publicly, for one…), I appreciate how you’re saying it. It’s more than just cookie-cutter wisdom, that’s for sure!

  5. Mission for change? « Two Notes Ahead Says:

    [...] for change? Yesterday, as a response to Nick’s comment, I wrote that (and I paraphrase here) a blog that I find of value has a “mission for change [...]

  6. ryanstephens Says:

    Aidan,

    Thanks for consistently giving me something to think about.

    Charlie,

    One way to ensure Holiday ends up on the list is to submit your top 10.

Leave a Reply